I remember as a teenager telling my parents that the prohibition on Thanksgiving was the most difficult one to explain to other kids at school.
Standard worldly kid retorts were:
1. "What's wrong with giving thanks to God? Aren't you thankful?"
2. "Is there something wrong with turkey and stuffing?"
3. "It's all about getting together with family."
And the best reply I could come up with was that the original Thanksgiving was somehow an example of "interfaith" and that JWs don't support that. Interfaith?!?
So finally I would just say, "You know, most JWs agree that No Thanksgiving is probably the most difficult holiday to explain to a non-JW. It only sort-of makes sense to some JWs."
Translation: You'd have to be a cult member to understand.
om